Just how ‘toxic’ is MDF, exactly?? [video #290] (2024)

Introduction

#mdf #formaldehyde #healthyworking

In this video I delve a little deeper into the whole “MDF & Formaldehyde” issue, and try to find out exactly how unhealthy wood is, generally. Enjoy!

Please use the ‘Like’ button if you liked this video.

Please subscribe if you think you’d like to see more

Further reading:-

HSE FAQ on MDF & Formaldehyde - bit.ly/MDF_FAQ
Article in The Guardian - bit.ly/Guardian_MDF
Medite on Formaldehyde youtu.be/ftffBakPlxQ
Medite - mdfosb.com
Medite MR MDF data sheet- mdfosb.com/assets/uploads/downloads/MEDITE-MR.pdf
- - - - -

My ‘social’ links in one place - bit.ly/10minute-links

Support me directly - bit.ly/donate_to_10minuteworkshop

Support me on Patreon - www.patreon.com/10minuteworkshop

Full list of ‘Stuff I use’ at bit.ly/stuff_I_use

Connect with me on twitter @10minuteshop

Connect with me on Instagram - @10minuteworkshop

+++++++

As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases made through these links.

Wherever possible links are to actual products used, but this is not always possible e.g. some products are not available in the US, so something similar has been linked to instead.

Amazon UK - www.amazon.co.uk/shop/petermillard1


Used/featured in this video/series

Air quality monitor with HCHO & TVOC - amzn.to/2GmNacS (US: amzn.to/2GmmTvo)

Festool Kapex 120 - amzn.to/2oYOXeq (US: amzn.to/2o7D3zL)

Festool TS55 Tracksaw - amzn.to/2pGvzDS (US: amzn.to/2oOgGhw)

Festool Domino - amzn.to/2pVSnMk (US: amzn.to/2o7E22Q)

Festool ETS 150/5 - amzn.to/2sapsq9 (US: amzn.to/2ssbZgq)

Festool RTS 400 - amzn.to/2x6zGZW (US: amzn.to/2i84yXn)

Festool Granat abrasive - amzn.to/2A3zU6k (US: amzn.to/2iNk2Rr)

Mirka Abralon - amzn.to/2v07kCc (US: amzn.to/2K7su5W)

Festool lever clamp - amzn.to/2pOohLD (US: amzn.to/2pnFZIM)

Festool PDC 18/4 - amzn.to/2s3J0eq (US: amzn.to/2tWUHEL)

Festool coloured boxes - amzn.to/2v7CcSN (US: amzn.to/2vIqU4n)

Bessey Duo Klamp - amzn.to/2tsSWQs (US:amzn.to/2sVaRBH)

Moldex 6810 in-ear defenders - amzn.to/2sTwQJE (US:amzn.to/2sThGo1)

Hultafors Talmeter tape measure - amzn.to/2pHwnbH (US: amzn.to/2oqLQc9)

Bahco 6” combi square - amzn.to/2oumhX4 (US: amzn.to/2ouSg9k)

Bradawl - amzn.to/2qWTbln (US: amzn.to/2pZqVRm)

Mirok square - etsy.me/2MC0RTZ

Content

Hi there, I'm, Peter Miller.

And in today's video, I want to talk to you about toxic NDF it's coming up next.

So if you saw a copy of the Guardian at the weekend, you probably will have seen this story.

What is it? Our MDF furniture brought toxic fumes into our home it's, a story of a couple just down the road from me and Chyzyk who paid a lot of money for some fitted furniture.

It gave off a lot of fumes to the extent that they couldn't be in the room.

The couple after on some haranguing, the firm's supplying it high-end firm to say, a lot of money, the farm supplying this ripped it out.

The couple had had the air quality monitored at great expense as well.

And after apparently, a considerable amount of back and forth over 18 months, the couple were refunded, apparently, the firm offered to replace it completely painted in water-based paints.

And they declined a later date.

According to the story continued report.

They went another another route and it's a sorry story and I feel I feel for everybody involved in.

It I've got to say from the supplying firm.

You don't want this kind of publicity, you know, and this sort of bad press or unhappy clients.

And for the couple concerned as well, there's a last thing, it's, bad enough having builders and blokes in your home, it's it's, even worse, when it doesn't work out for you I wanted to do a story about MDF and the relative health concerns about it for a while.

And this is a convenient thing to hang it on I'm, not going to discuss the story in particular I'd encourage everybody to go and read the story themselves, there's a lot of holes in the story, a lot of bits that seemed to have been skimmed over and I.

Think that headline are MDF fellowship brought toxic fumes into our home is very carefully written very carefully worded because it implies.

So the casual reader lets the MDF at fault.

But I think upon reading the story, my impression was certainly that it's the paint that's problematic, not the end yet, but we'll see I've contacted everybody involved in the story.

The the couple the firm supplying the furniture, the air quality guys and the journalists, the reporter who wrote it and we'll see if anybody gets back to me it's early days, yet, the story only came out on Saturday and I'm recording this on Monday, but I wanted to talk about MDF and the potential health risks because it's one of those things that comes up all the time, especially about MDF and formaldehyde.

Now if anybody ever asks me about formaldehyde and MDF and the health risks, I typically point them towards this document.

This is the British Health and Safety Executive frequently asked questions sheet, it's about five pages long on MDF and the dangers of working with MDF and exposure to India.

And it does talk extensively about formaldehyde.

If I'd I'll quote from this there's, a link to this in the video description below and there's a link to the Guardian article as well.

I can't.

Remember, if I mentioned that as well, then we just quote this, what is formaldehyde? And where does it come from? Formaldehyde is a simple, but essential organic chemical that occurs, naturally in most forms of life, including people some foods we eat and trees all products made from wood, will therefore emit some naturally occurring formaldehyde it's widely used in the manufacture of numerous products, including shampoos plastics, carpets textiles, resins, glues, etc.

Yeah, it's it's formaldehyde as in in all wood, what's, the problem with that, well, it's also suspected of causing cancer in high doses from our head is classified in the UK and the EU as a carcinogen.

And it carries the hazard statement suspected of causing cancer The Guardian article firmly hanging its hat on a formaldehyde angle with MDF.

So let's continue on that for a little bit there's, a couple of sort of money quotes from this Health and Safety Executive guidance.

Let me quote, direct the most common binder for boards intended for dry environments will come out of that is urea.

Formaldehyde.

Other binders may be used depending on the grade of board and its intended end use, for example, melamine urea, formaldehyde phenolic resins and I'm going to struggle with a certain poly metric, diphenyl, methane, diisocyanate or PM.

Di are generally used in boards that are required for improved moisture.

Resistance PM di, binder is not formaldehyde based.

And consequently does not emit any formaldehyde.

The exact constitutes of that an MDF board will vary from product product, no kidding.

So how much formaldehyde is released by MDF board again, quoting from the Health and Safety Executive, Board there's, lots of technical stuff about the specifications or whatnot.

But basically to European of formaldehyde classes, II 1 and E 2, the left release of formaldehyde in e1 boards is point 1 posts parts per million.

And in e2 boards, it's between point 1 and point 3 ppm, money quite again in Europe, the majority of manufacturers produce only low emission boards.

There are some boards available on the market with extremely low for malahide emissions and some with no added formaldehyde.

So essentially the only formaldehyde that's being released comes from the wood that the formaldehyde is that the MDF is made from.

And yes, contrary to popular opinion.

Mdf is made of wood manufactures from outside Europe may produce boards that have higher emissions.

So this brings us back to the money quote from before as well PM di binders are generally used in boards that require improved moisture resistance.

So if you're buying MDF fairly obviously buy a board that's manufactured in the EU to these standards and preferably use moisture-resistant.

And there better still use a known brand as I do the brand that I use is med, 8mr MDF, and they will produce a spec sheet that goes with it.

And again, buried right at the bottom of this technical specs sheet, Medaille MDR conforms to the e1 formaldehyde levels as well as also the lower levels required by CA, our B phase to no carb, Californian, Air, Resources Board phase to change their levels to a much more stringent level of 0.05 parts per million has a target level on point.

One parts per million as an action level.

This gets a bits of jargon in a bit sort of technical.

But basically it it.

All prompted me to go out and buy one of these little guys because as much as I care about the health of my clients and their homes actually care quite a lot about in mine as well.

This is a an air quality monitor again, there's a link in the video description to these.

You can buy these for about 40 odd quid.

If you prepare to wait for a couple of weeks to get them from China, or you can buy one from Amazon for about 80, which is what I did these as well as giving a fairly crude air quality indicator only goes down to PM 2.5, or as the other one that I have goes down to a third of a micron.

It does give temperature humidity, but importantly, it gives HCHO or formaldehyde levels and TV OC.

So total volatile organic compounds.

Those were referred to in The Guardian article as being extremely high in this room, which is why I think it's more of a paint problem personally, but read the article make up your own mind, but I bought this and I was painting in here.

Last week, I closed, the workshop up over the weekend wasn't in at all.

And when I came in and put this on I was amazed, how high the levels were considering I only use moisture-resistant med, 8, MDF, boards and I only use ultra-low v, OC, water-based paints so I open the doors and windows up a little bit.

And after about 5 or 10 minutes, the levels have gone right down.

These levels are for formaldehyde 0.04 7.

Let me get my crib sheet and what's.

The safe level, WH, 0.08 and we're at point, O, 4 1 so half that and total of EOC levels, ideally between 0.6 and 1 and we're at point, three so we're, well within those limits for a home.

And this is in a workshop where I cut things up and paint them, which makes me wonder.

What exactly are we worrying about? In fact, it made me wonder, what sort of levels I'd get on this if I exposed it to actual real tree wood, ok.

So I'm on my workbench, which is MDF, but it is much the reason and there for me is completely sealed.

I've got my little air quality monitor here given its nice low reading.

So what I'm going to do a whole load of wood last week for a curved cut test check out the YouTube channel? If you haven't seen that and all I'm going to do I'm going to surround my little air quality monitor with natural timber and see what happens to those levels because I'm curious I wonder, if this perfectly natural grows on trees, timber, well, actually produce similar or higher levels we're, just gonna let that run for a while so 20 minutes or so close exposure.

And we've got levels of over 0.14 formaldehyde and almost point 840 VOCs.

They both exceed comfortably exceed the CRB of the Californian Air, Resources, Board levels and also exceeds the dual nature of the World Health, Organization's guideline for indoor formaldehyde, um and that's, just from wood.

So where does that leave us exactly? Well? Obviously articles like this one aren't going to do the independent maker an installer community, any favors and I guess? One of the extra things we'll have to start keeping in our installs kit is one of these little monitors little monitor formaldehyde and TV OSI levels check the room before you start and check the room when you finish, hopefully that would Olay any fears.

Obviously if you're not already, then you probably should be using a branded known board from a known manufacturer who will produce a spec sheet, hopefully that not just complies with the current European standards.

But also the much more stringent carb phase 2 standards as well.

And if you or your clients do her any questions or queries, then point them in the direction of this excellent Health and Safety, Executive, FAQ sheet, which should hopefully allay any fears.

They may have you have to wonder, though what it is we're shooting for when a few bits of natural timber wrapped around the air quality monitor is enough to put it beyond the levels at the whu-oh and carb to actually recommend I have no answer to that.

So that's it for this week.

Thanks for watching I'll.

See you next time you.

Just how ‘toxic’ is MDF, exactly?? [video #290] (2024)

FAQs

How toxic is MDF? ›

Conclusion. In conclusion, we would just like to reiterate that while may MDF carry a tiny fraction of harmful substances, it is completely safe. The concentration of Formaldehyde in it is well below the safety line and we ensure ample measures to ensure minimal to no emissions.

How long does MDF emit formaldehyde? ›

MDF made with UF may emit formaldehyde gas for months or years after it is manufactured. Over the last few years it has become more common for manufacturers of MDF to: Lower the amount of added formaldehyde in the UF resin.

Is MDF still carcinogenic? ›

The main concern regarding the health risks of MDF is the use of urea-formaldehyde adhesives as the bonding agent during the creation of the panels. Formaldehyde has been thought to have cancer risks. However, studies linking cancer to formaldehyde have not been conclusive.

Does MDF still contain formaldehyde? ›

The atmosphere created by machining or sanding MDF board contains a mixture of softwood dust and hardwood dust (if it is present). In addition, there will also be free formaldehyde, dust particles onto which formaldehyde is adsorbed and potentially, the resin binder itself and its derivatives.

Why is MDF banned in the US? ›

Health issues with MDF board

Because of the health hazards MDF presents, the U.S. government passed the Formaldehyde Standards for Composite Wood Products Act in 2010, which sets limits on how much formaldehyde home products can contain—in this case, a max of 0.11 ppm (parts per millions).

Why is MDF cancerous? ›

MDF board. MDF board is a timber product made from hardwood and softwood fibres that are glued together with wax and a resin adhesive containing urea-formaldehyde. Both wood dust and formaldehyde are Group 1 carcinogens. When working with wood products, dust and free formaldehyde are released.

What are the symptoms of MDF poisoning? ›

In extreme cases Formaldehyde Poisoning may include low blood pressure (hypotension), abnormalities of heart rhythm, irregular breathing, restlessness, unconsciousness and coma.

Is MDF banned in any countries? ›

In more than 30 years of usage, there is no evidence that MDF is a health risk. It has never been banned in any part of the USA or any other country (contrary to ill-informed rumours that surface from time to time that it has been banned in some country or other) and there is no reason for it to be so.

Does baking soda remove formaldehyde? ›

Baking soda reduces odor and gently cleans clothes. To do this, pour some baking soda into the warm water, swirl it around gently to mix the ingredients, and submerge your clothes in the mixture for at least 8 hours to remove formaldehyde.

Should you avoid MDF? ›

MDF is vulnerable to extreme heat Remember that engineered wood is made out of wax and/or resin-like compounds. This is why you should not leave MDF units in proximity of heaters, radiators, fireplaces, ovens, stoves as well as out in a hot summer. 4. MDF can't support too much weight.

Has MDF been banned in America? ›

The material is often bound together with a urea formaldehyde resin, although formaldehyde-free boards are now also available. Despite rumours to the contrary MDF has not been banned in the USA (or anywhere else), nor is it likely to be. The USA in fact uses more of it than any other county.

Is MDF the next asbestos? ›

The wood industry has rejected the allegations surrounding MDF, which is now the centre of a multi-billion pound market. David Duke-Evans, director-general of the Wood Panel Industries Federation, which represents MDF manufacturers, said: 'It has nothing in common with asbestos.

Does IKEA use particle board or MDF? ›

Particle board, a strong composite material, represents approximately half of all the wood-based material used in our products in FY22. Figures do not include paper used in IKEA products.

What are the symptoms of formaldehyde poisoning? ›

Ingestion of aqueous solutions of formaldehyde can result in severe corrosive injury to the esophagus and stomach. Nausea, vomiting, diarrhea, abdominal pain, inflammation of the stomach, and ulceration and perforation of the oropharynx, epiglottis, esophagus, and stomach may occur.

Where should you not use MDF? ›

There are a few areas where MDF should never be used – kitchen or bathroom cabinets and trim in the bathrooms. These are the two areas we see the most failure because of moisture. Window sills are also problematic if the windows have any sort of condensation or leaking problems.

What is a safe alternative to MDF? ›

Although zero formaldehyde varieties are available, let's take a look at 3 less harmful and more sustainable alternatives.
  • Ecoboard / Novo Base. These straw based sheet materials are a great alternative to MDF. ...
  • Richlite / PaperStone. ...
  • EKOply / Ecoplastic Sheet.

Is MDF more toxic than plywood? ›

The level of formaldehyde offgassing is higher than in plywood, even if both are CARB 2 certified – 0.11 ppm in MDF compared to 0.05 ppm for plywood. MDF made with formaldehyde should be avoided where possible in a healthy home.

Can MDF be formaldehyde free? ›

MEDITE ECOLOGIQUE is an MDF panel with Zero added Formaldehyde. Developed specifically for use in environmentally sensitive interior applications, where formaldehyde emissions need to be kept to the minimum. FSC® Certified.

Should you wear a mask when cutting MDF? ›

Don't Cut It Without a Mask

Cutting and milling MDF produces a lot of dust and fine particles which contains high levels of urea-formaldehyde due to the adhesive resins contained within the material. Wearing a mask is highly advised as the dust particles produced contain formaldehyde which is a know carcinogen.

Is MDF as bad as asbestos? ›

Like asbestos, MDF has been touted as a wonder product, but like asbestos it may be as equally as deadly, at least in the production phases. So much so, that I won't really think it should be used by DIY enthusiasts. Woodworkers should stick to plywood.

Why is everything made of MDF? ›

Builders and homeowners love using MDF because it's durable and highly cost-effective. It's also a solution for a wide range of applications, from doors to storage cabinets, molding and trim. MDF offers great stability, even when there are significant changes in temperature or humidity.

What does formaldehyde do to the brain? ›

This aldehyde is a well-established neurotoxin that affects memory, learning, and behavior. In addition, in several pathological conditions, including Alzheimer's disease, an increase in the expression of formaldehyde-generating enzymes and elevated levels of formaldehyde in brain have been reported.

How long does formaldehyde stay in the air? ›

The data suggests it takes about two years for formaldehyde in newly built or remodeled homes to off-gas down to levels of the average home. However, higher humidity and temperatures can make VOCs off-gas faster.

What does formaldehyde do to the body? ›

At low levels, breathing in formaldehyde can cause eye, nose and throat irritation. At higher levels, formaldehyde exposure can cause skin rashes, shortness of breath, wheezing and changes in lung function.

What is better than MDF? ›

Plywood looks more like real wood.

Since plywood is made with wood strips, its surfaces take on the solid-wood appearance better than MDF. Higher grades of plywood are smooth and quite attractive, with plenty of grain, yet none of the knotholes that can mar solid wood.

What is the best mask for MDF dust? ›

The best mask for MDF dust is one that is equipped with a P3 filter. P3 filters are designed to filter out at least 99.97% of airborne particles, including those as small as 0.3 microns. This makes them highly effective at filtering out the fine dust particles created when cutting MDF.

Does painting MDF make it safe? ›

During the 'machining' process, however, is the only time that MDF poses any kind of health risk. The reality is that once the MDF is cut and finished with sealant or paint, it is no more harmful than a tomato.

Does vinegar break down formaldehyde? ›

Add vinegar to the laundry.

Add a cup of white vinegar to your rinse cycle to help wash out formaldehyde better.

What product in your home is most likely to emit formaldehyde? ›

In homes, the most significant sources of formaldehyde are likely to be pressed wood products made using adhesives that contain urea-formaldehyde (UF) resins.

Does washing clothes remove formaldehyde? ›

Rinse your clothing in cold water and allow it to air dry.

Air drying will help to get rid of any formaldehyde left over in your clothes.

What is high grade MDF? ›

MDF is a high grade, composite material. It is made from recycled wood fibers and resin. It is dried and pressed to produce dense, stable sheets. Because of this process, MDF does not warp or crack like wood.

Is MDF safe for kids? ›

MDF is allowed in food safe applications and for children's toys (the only restriction even in Europe is regarding the paint you apply to the MDF).

How many years does MDF last? ›

The average lifespan of MDF products given in the literature ranges from 14 to 20 years.

What happens to MDF at the end of its life? ›

However, MDF can be recycled, which is the most sustainable scenario for its end-of-life stage. There are two scenarios for MDF products – furniture, flooring, and household items – at the end of their life: They can end up in landfills and don't decompose. In this case, it keeps its role as carbon storage.

What is most cheap furniture made of? ›

MDF, laminates, softwood, and melamine are also hallmarks of cheap furniture. Of course these materials are great for less used spaces and children's bedrooms, but if you spot these materials in cheap bedroom furniture, be sure to know that it won't be high quality.

Do carpenters use MDF? ›

MDF wood is ranked among the most versatile carpentry material and for a good reason. It's incredibly durable, has an average density, making it an excellent choice for numerous projects like making cabinets and shelves.

How can you tell MDF from particle board? ›

MDF has a smooth finish as it consists of wood grains that are of the same size. Particle-boards do not have a smooth surface as they consist of wood shavings and chips. MDF has a higher density level than particle-board. Particle-boards have a lesser density level.

What cancers are caused by formaldehyde? ›

Which cancers are associated with exposure to formaldehyde? Studies of workers exposed to high levels of formaldehyde, such as industrial workers and embalmers, have found that formaldehyde causes myeloid leukemia and rare cancers, including cancers of the paranasal sinuses, nasal cavity, and nasopharynx.

Can new furniture make you sick? ›

Imagine buying a new furniture set and noticing a strong, chemical odor in your house days, even months later. For some people, headaches, asthma, allergies and even serious diseases like cancer may follow. It's called furniture off-gassing. Furniture can release toxic chemicals into the air we breathe.

How do you neutralize formaldehyde? ›

The reaction of formaldehyde with urea and acid will neutralize the formaldehyde.

Where is MDF most commonly used? ›

MDF is widely used in the manufacturing of furniture, kitchen cabinets, moldings, millwork, door parts, and laminate flooring.

Should you use MDF in a bathroom? ›

Moisture resistant MDF is made for use in areas where the moisture content in the air is higher than normal - for instance, an average bathroom. The properties given to the material during the manufacturing process prevent the boards from sucking up moisture that may be present in the air.

Which is better MDF or PVC? ›

MDF is environmentally friendly and can be easily recycled for reuse as it is made up of wood fibre. PVC is not degradable or biodegradable after its use as the breakdown does not occur easily. MDF is resistant to chipping and ripping and hence it is easy to mould.

Is MDF toxic to breathe? ›

The noncarcinogenic effects of MDF dust and formaldehyde include eye and skin irritation [2, 7, 8], dermatitis, [9] respiratory illnesses such as nasal inflammation [10], asthma [7, 11, 12], bronchitis [13], coughing, loud breathing, and wheezing [11, 12], and lower chest discomfort [8].

Is MDF banned in the US? ›

The material is often bound together with a urea formaldehyde resin, although formaldehyde-free boards are now also available. Despite rumours to the contrary MDF has not been banned in the USA (or anywhere else), nor is it likely to be. The USA in fact uses more of it than any other county.

Is it safe to cut MDF board? ›

Don't Cut It Without a Mask

Cutting and milling MDF produces a lot of dust and fine particles which contains high levels of urea-formaldehyde due to the adhesive resins contained within the material. Wearing a mask is highly advised as the dust particles produced contain formaldehyde which is a know carcinogen.

What are the side effects of MDF wood? ›

When MDF is manufactured, VOCs are released into the air. These VOCs can cause respiratory problems, headaches, and nausea. Dust produced during manufacture is harmful to breathing: Dust produced during the manufacture of MDF is harmful to breathing. This dust can contain harmful chemicals, such as formaldehyde.

How long does it take for particle board to off gas? ›

Bottom Line: How Long it Takes to Off-gas Formaldehyde from Homes. The data suggests it takes about two years for formaldehyde in newly built or remodeled homes to off-gas down to levels of the average home. However, higher humidity and temperatures can make VOCs off-gas faster.

Why not to use MDF? ›

MDF lacks the directional grain that gives solid wood and plywood its strength and structural integrity. Even though a lot of shelving and cabinets are remade from MDF, they require a solid timber frame to provide support or must be fixed in a way to ensure it does not sag over time.

What is the cleanest way to cut MDF? ›

The easy and effective way to cut the MDF is using a table saw with a carbide-tipped blade. To avoid dust build-up, the blade should be carbide-tipped, and the table saw should have a vacuum removal system.

Will Lowes cut MDF board for you? ›

In addition to plywood, Lowe's will also cut MDF, particle board, and melamine for you. These are all similar materials that can be difficult to cut for the average person. Of course, Lowe's also offers standard wood cutting services for things like 2x4s and other common boards.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Carlyn Walter

Last Updated:

Views: 5285

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Carlyn Walter

Birthday: 1996-01-03

Address: Suite 452 40815 Denyse Extensions, Sengermouth, OR 42374

Phone: +8501809515404

Job: Manufacturing Technician

Hobby: Table tennis, Archery, Vacation, Metal detecting, Yo-yoing, Crocheting, Creative writing

Introduction: My name is Carlyn Walter, I am a lively, glamorous, healthy, clean, powerful, calm, combative person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.